AI is coming for primary care

11


Listen to the article

7 min

This audio is auto-generated. Please let us know if you have feedback.

LAS VEGAS — Primary care appears set for a drastic reimagining. Thanks to artificial intelligence, experts are prognosticating that Americans’ main point of contact with the healthcare system could look wildly different in just a few years, as the technology empowers primary care doctors to manage more patients — or replaces the physicians altogether.

Experts have long dreamed about how AI could remake the U.S.’ broken primary care chassis. But these fantasties took on a new seriousness earlier this month, when wearables manufacturer Oura announced it planned to acquire Counsel Health, an AI-based primary care company.

It’s a major bet from Oura, which offers a line of popular smart rings that track users’ heart rates, respiration and other biometrics, that AI will actually create a new front door to healthcare — and that consumers are ready for the change.

“Primary care today is sort of fraying and not serving the modern population the way we need it to,” Dr. Muthu Alagappan, Counsel’s founder and CEO, said during a Tuesday panel at the HLTH conference in Las Vegas. “So it’s time to reimagine and question all the underlying elements of that model for the modern era.”

Experts have long warned that U.S. primary care is on the verge of collapse. About one-third of Americans don’t have a primary care provider, and that’s only expected to worsen as the population ages, according the Physicians Foundation.

Only one-fourth of new doctors are entering primary care — the lowest rate in a decade — while many family physicians close shop or sell their practices, burned out after years of insufficient reimbursement, copious “pajama time” and other challenges.

The takeoff of generative AI in the early 2020s sparked concerns that the technology, now able to understand and respond to complex queries, could eventually replace physicians. The debate intensified with the advent of agentic AI, which can autonomously complete tasks with minimal human supervision. Still, the consensus remained that AI would augment rather than replace physicians.

But that consensus appears to be weakening — at least when it comes to primary care, where the industry seems increasingly comfortable with AI infringing on physicians’ duties if it means the technology could solve endemic issues in the space.

“Most people experience primary care as very inaccessible, very difficult, and someone who is just a gateway to other services. I think if you treat it as a kind of routing function, then it does make sense that AI should have a really powerful role in that,” Dr. Sarah Russell, who works on healthcare and life sciences projects at Anthropic, said during a Monday panel.

“People often use provocative terms, like, ‘We’re going to replace clinicians. We’re going to replace people.’ The truth is, there are some tasks you want to replace,” Dr. Kyu Rhee, the president and CEO of the National Association of Community Health Centers, said. “I do believe there’s a future where if we leverage the right type of AI, the same panel that I managed with 1,500 patients with a team of 11, maybe I can manage 2,500 patients in a continuous way beyond the traditional visit-based model.”

Still, thorny questions continue to swirl around how much AI should usurp tasks traditionally performed by a primary care physician, and what degree of autonomy the technology will be allowed.

What will the average primary care interaction look like if AI is deployed at scale? A standalone AI chatbot trained on medical information? An AI chatbot with physician oversight? A doctor with AI running in the background?

Physician groups are adamant that AI will take over administrative work — scheduling, triaging, charting — but will never replace human providers. People value their relationship with their primary care doctor too highly, according to Dr. John Whyte, CEO of the American Medical Association.

“Patients don’t want to hear a cancer diagnosis from an LLM,” Whyte said during the Monday panel.

But physicians working on the front lines of AI are less certain that the physician-patient relationship is as untouchable as it may appear.

Patients don’t care whether they’re talking to an actual doctor or an AI chatbot, as long as they’re receiving care how and when they need it, argued Dr. Ricky Bloomfield, Oura’s chief medical officer.

“If you ask a patient what they want, they’re not going to say, ‘I want an AI doctor, or I don’t want an AI doctor,’” Bloomfield said during the Monday panel. “They just want to be healthier, and they want to be healthier faster and at a lower cost.” 

Counsel, which Oura plans to spend $625 million to acquire, trained software to make medical decisions, to work alongside doctors and multiply their capacity. It has a team of clinical AI agents working for a physician — “almost an Iron Man suit for that clinician,”  Alagappan said — that allows them to incorporate medical records and clinical guidelines to make more effective decisions at the point of care.

The care model is almost entirely based around chat, allowing physicians to take care of multiple patients at the same time. By joining with Oura, the company’s AI can now also absorb the wearables’ continuous biometric data to get a fuller and more actionable picture of a user’s health, according to the Counsel CEO.

When Tom Hale, Oura’s CEO, had an eye infection, he was able to chat with his Counsel doctor about his care plan immediately. That gave him “an incredible window into what we could offer,” Hale said in a session on HLTH’s main stage.

“We could offer something that was like, if you didn’t have a doctor, you could get care. And there’s a human in the loop who could take action. And maybe in the future, in the glorious future, it’ll all be completely autonomous self-driving doctors, that the machines give you,” Hale said.

Experts are coalescing around the idea that AI will create a spectrum of primary care — through your phone in the palm of your hand, or in person at your family physician’s office. It’ll be up to the patient to decide.

“The view that I have no contact with a human and I’m just relying on this sort of latent agent to monitor me probably is not something that we all want, necessarily,” Jonathan Kolstad, a health economist and the founder of Knit Health, a healthcare AI startup, said in an interview. But, “I think there’s a view which is actually really exciting, which is primary care doctors can be empowered to engage with you in a way they haven’t been able to.”

Either way, AI has already become fundamental to the experience of providing care, according to Anthropic’s Russell.

Russell said she frequently asks OpenEvidence, a clinical AI platform, about patient symptoms or the latest research studies to ensure her care measures up to the latest standards.

“When I see patients now, I can’t imagine doing it without AI,” Russell said.

Close
Your custom text © Copyright 2020. All rights reserved.
Close